grieving is a form of learning

Share
grieving is a form of learning
Grief is not a stage you pass through.
Not a checklist.
Not five steps with an exit at the end.

I learned this the slow way, in a body that had already decided, at fourteen, how it was going to handle the unbearable. And decided again at eighteen. Buried it. Kept moving. For fifteen years I built from the head only, not integrating or listening to the body. It worked, in the sense that it let me function. What I didn’t understand yet was that functioning and healing, or in this case grief processing, are not the same.

I used to read that gap as a personal failing - some deficiency in how I processed things, a toughness that had curdled into avoidance. It took a neuroscience degree, years into this work, to understand that what I was calling willpower had a name in the research literature. Several names, actually. And none of them were about character.

So I want to write about what grief actually does, underneath what most of us were handed - the idea that it has phases, that it ends, that there’s a right way to do it and a wrong way, and that if you’re still carrying it years later, something in you failed to graduate.

None of that is true, psychologically or somatically, and also not in the research.

If you are working through grief right now, take a moment before you read on. Notice whether this is the right thing to read today. It might be. You are the guardian of your own system, and you can stop, or come back later.

Grief is a whole-body event, not a mood

The American Psychological Association’s definition of grief, as it’s taught in clinical trainings, names it as the anguish that follows significant loss - and it includes far more than sadness.

grief - n. the anguish experienced after significant loss, usually the death of a beloved person. Grief is often distinguished from bereavement and mourning. Not all bereavements result in a strong grief response, and not all grief is given public expression (see disenfranchised grief). Grief often includes physiological distress, separation anxiety, confusion, yearning, obsessive dwelling on the past, and apprehension about the future. Intense grief can become life-threatening through disruption of the immune system, self-neglect, and suicidal thoughts. Grief may also take the form of regret for something lost, remorse for something done, or sorrow for a mishap to oneself.

Grief researcher J. William Worden, whose work is foundational in the field, frames grieving not as something that simply happens to us but as a set of tasks: accepting the reality of the loss, letting ourselves feel the full weight of it, adapting to a life that has to be lived without the person, and finding a way to carry them forward while still moving into a life that continues. Worden’s framework doesn’t put these in a fixed order. Some people need to feel the loss before they can accept it. Some do it in reverse. Some circle through all four for years.

What struck me, reading through this material again as a therapist in training rather than as someone inside it, is how little of this maps onto the “stages” most of us heard about - denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance, done. Those stages came initially from Elisabeth Kübler-Ross’s work with people who were dying, BUT she never offered them as a fixed sequence. Unfortunately, this memorable list got frozen in popular culture while her own thinking kept developing. Grief doesn’t move in one direction. People circle back, skip ahead, and then still return.

Mary-Frances O’Connor has spent more than two decades studying what grief does - not what it feels like, which poets have covered thoroughly, but the mechanics of it, in the brain and in the rest of the body. She directs the Grief, Loss and Social Stress lab at the University of Arizona, and her two books, The Grieving Brain and The Grieving Body, are the closest thing I’ve found to a rigorous answer to a question I carried for a long time without knowing how to ask it: why understanding a loss still leaves you unable to feel it move.

The brain treats a person like a place

O’Connor’s central argument in The Grieving Brain is that grief is fundamentally a learning problem rather than only an emotional one. The brain builds an internal map of where our loved ones are - physically, but also relationally, how close we feel to them, whether we can find them when we need them. When someone dies, that map doesn’t update on its own. The brain keeps predicting their return, because prediction, not raw sensory input, is what the brain mostly runs on. It fills in gaps with what it already expects. A sound at the usual hour still gets read as a car arriving outside, a key in the door, for months and maybe even years after there is no one left to walk through it.

This is why grief takes so long to metabolize even for people who understand, intellectually, exactly what happened. Understanding is abstract knowledge. The brain trusts lived, repeated experience over abstraction - it takes many mornings of an empty side of the bed before the prediction actually updates. O’Connor traces part of this to a brain region called the posterior cingulate cortex, which appears to track psychological closeness the way other parts of the brain track physical location. Her research team ran the first fMRI study of grief in 2001 and it laid groundwork for a finding she returns to throughout the book: losing someone doesn’t just hurt. It leaves the brain holding a map that no longer matches the world, and rebuilding that map is slow, effortful, biological work - more like relearning a language vs. simply “getting over” something.

The charge that never got to move

The body has its own version of this, and it was the one I met first, years before I had any of the research.

Before there are words for a loss, the nervous system has already registered it. When someone we’re bonded with is gone, it treats the loss like any other major threat to safety - with activation. Charge moves up. Cortisol rises. And if that charge has somewhere to go - if there’s someone present, if there’s space held, if the body is allowed to shake and cry and make sound - it moves through. It discharges. This is stress physiology, not just a nice way to put it.

But if the charge has nowhere to go - no one to witness it, no time made for it, a world that says take as long as you need and then, days later, asks whether you’ve answered the email - the nervous system does something else. Instead of discharging, it gets stuck. Sometimes the one holding it back is us, following what we learned about how grief is supposed to look. And stuck grief doesn’t disappear. It just changes shape. It can surface later as anxiety that has no clear object, or as a depression that doesn’t quite look like sadness, or as a numbness so complete a person will describe themselves as watching their own life from somewhere outside it.

I did not have a name for any of this at eighteen. I only knew that not thinking about it worked. Something like this can be paused, intact, and still waiting, for a very long time, for the conditions it needs to move.

I think of the outdated map and the undischarged charge as two descriptions of one unfinished process. The map is the brain’s record of where the people we love are. The charge is what the body’s stress response mobilised and never got to release. Just ‘knowing’ the truth changes neither. Repetition does, along with the right conditions of being held and supported.

Grief is not only in your head

The Grieving Body, O’Connor’s follow-up, moves the same question into the rest of the physiology.

Grief measurably strains the cardiovascular system. O’Connor cites research by epidemiologist Elizabeth Mostofsky and cardiologist Geoffrey Tofler finding that a heart attack was roughly twenty-one times more likely in the twenty-four hours immediately following the death of a loved one, compared to any other day. The risk fades with each passing day but doesn’t disappear quickly - after a parent’s death, longer-term risk of heart disease and stroke stays measurably elevated. This isn’t metaphorical heartbreak. It’s blood pressure, heart rate variability, and inflammatory markers responding to loss the way they’d respond to any major physiological threat.

The immune system follows a similar pattern. The first study connecting bereavement to immune function was published by Australian psychiatrist Roger Bartrop in The Lancet in 1977, and decades of research since have generally found the same thing: grief increases inflammation, and people going through severe grief responses show poorer immune function, more susceptibility to infection, less benefit from things like flu vaccines. O’Connor connects this to something called the theory of sickness behavior - a finding from psychoneuroimmunology showing that high inflammation itself changes motivation and mood, independent of what a person is consciously thinking. Withdrawal, low energy, disinterest in seeing people: some portion of what looks like depression during grief may be inflammation doing exactly what it’s supposed to do when the body registers injury. It’s the body doing its job, not a failure of willpower or persistence, which is how it can look from the outside.

When the external pacemaker is gone

One idea from The Grieving Body is the concept of a loved one as an external pacemaker. Drawing on a 1984 paper by psychiatrist Myron Hofer, O’Connor describes how attachment relationships regulate our physiology in ways we don’t notice until the person is gone - heart rate, sleep cycles, hormone rhythms, all quietly synchronized to another person’s presence. Hofer’s original research was with infant rats separated from their mothers: remove the mother, and multiple physiological systems in the pups destabilize at once, not because of one single mechanism, but because her presence had been regulating several systems simultaneously without either of them “trying.”

Attachment theory, going back to Bowlby’s work - grounded partly in his studies of children separated from parents during wartime - predicts two responses when that regulation disappears: protest, then despair. Protest looks like searching, restlessness, an inability to settle. Despair looks like giving up on the search, and physiologically, it tracks with rising inflammation.

Here’s what no one in my close environment understood. Most people who lose a parent still have another parent, a sibling, an aunt, someone left to be an external pacemaker while the nervous system relearns how to regulate alone. When both parents are gone within a few years of each other, in adolescence, there is no one left holding that role. Not because anyone failed to show up. There was simply no one structurally positioned to be the regulation a still-developing nervous system needed. The body doesn’t get an exception from needing that. It just doesn’t get it, and it adapts anyway, however it can.

When grief becomes something else

O’Connor is precise about distinguishing ordinary grief, however severe, from what current clinical science calls complicated grief or prolonged grief disorder. The distinguishing features aren’t about intensity or how much someone cries. They’re about whether grief remains severely function-impairing well past the timeframe expected in a person’s culture - daily preoccupation with the person who died, a persistent sense that part of oneself is missing, an inability to reengage with life, lasting at minimum six months to a year. By her account, this affects a meaningful minority of bereaved people, but not most - most human beings, even through devastating loss, adapt with time and support. But for those who don’t, she’s careful to frame it the way you’d frame a bone that didn’t heal quite right, a complication in an otherwise natural process, and one that can respond to specific treatment.

What actually helps the body move it

The somatic view of grief work, which is where most of my own training now lives, doesn’t try to talk a person out of their grief or reframe it into something more comfortable. It works with the nervous system directly - self-contact, breath, sound, grounding through the legs and feet, small deliberate discharges of the very charge that got stuck in the first place. Not because talking doesn’t matter. It does. But because a body that has been holding activation for years doesn’t resolve that through insight alone. It resolves through completing what the nervous system started and couldn’t finish - the shaking, the crying, the sound, the movement that never got to happen at the time. And for many people, what matters most is simply being allowed to mourn, with the space to do it and someone there to hold and witness what is otherwise a deeply personal and lonely process.

This is the part that reorganized something for me. I could understand my losses completely, intellectually, and still felt nothing move when I tried to talk about them. For years I read that as evidence of something missing in me. It wasn’t. It was a body waiting for the right kind of attention, not more explanation.

Grieving as a form of learning

The idea O’Connor returns to by the end of The Grieving Brain is one I really like and use, both for myself and for my clients: grieving is a form of learning, and learning is something the brain does for an entire lifetime, not something with a deadline. That reframe did more for me than the usual “everyone grieves differently” reassurances ever managed. It gave the process a shape that didn’t require an end point to be valid.

So if you are grieving something - recent or decades old, allowed by the people around you or dismissed because they didn’t know more - the timeline was never the point. Whether you cried enough, whether you’re “still” sad, whether it’s been long enough that you should be over it: you may find these questions lose their grip once you stop measuring grief against a calendar. The nervous system tracks whether the charge got to move, and whether the map got the chance to update.

Some losses never get counted as losses at all. I’ll be writing about those separately, in the grief that has no name.

I don’t think it’s an accident that I eventually went back to school for a Master’s in neuroscience and psychology, wanting to understand not only that the body carries what it carries, but why, and how - even though, as O’Connor is honest enough to admit in her own book, we mostly don’t know; we have pieces of a puzzle nobody has finished assembling. Still, something in me needed the mechanism, not just the permission to feel. Looking back, that need may have been part of what she describes: a brain still updating its map, still learning, decades later, what it means that certain people are not coming back - and finding, along the way, that the learning itself is not the wound. It’s part of the healing.

If you’ve read this far, you might notice whether any of this landed in your body rather than just your understanding of it. If it did, you can stay with that for a moment, however it shows up. And if you’ve ever lost someone dear to you, I am sorry and sending all my compassion your way.

if you only remember five things

  • Grief has no stages to graduate from. Kübler-Ross never offered hers as a fixed sequence, and Worden describes grieving as tasks with no set order.
  • O’Connor’s research shows the brain keeps a map of where the people we love are. It updates through many repeated, lived experiences, not through understanding, which is why knowing what happened doesn’t make a loss move.
  • Grief is physical. Activation with nowhere to go gets stuck and can resurface later as anxiety, a depression that doesn’t look like sadness, or numbness. It also strains the heart and the immune system.
  • O’Connor describes a loved one as an external pacemaker for the nervous system. When no one is left to fill that role, a young body adapts alone, and what it needs later is attention, not more explanation.
  • Grieving is a form of learning, and learning has no deadline. “Have I cried enough?” and “Should I be over it by now?” lose their grip.

Until next time,
Alexandra

reach out

Whether you're navigating a difficult time - loss of vital energy, or a nervous system shaped by overwhelming experience - or simply longing for more aliveness, more movement where things have felt stuck, and a clearer sense of the patterns you carry, individual sessions offer a space to do this work with depth and care, grounded in your body's wisdom. A free discovery call is the first step.


If you want to stay in touch, I write regularly about the nervous system, stress, and trauma.